Experts clash over state of hospitality
There is confusion over the real state of recruitment in hospitality and tourism after conflicting reports on the sector's job market in September were published.
While online recruiter Monster's monthly Employment Index indicated a major drop in September vacancies, other experts insisted the market was continuing to rise.
According to Monster's figures, job recruitment activity in the hospitality and tourism sector experienced a "significant" fall in September, following three consecutive months of growth.
Alan Townsend, chief operating officer at Monster UK & Ireland, said: "The index findings show a mixed picture in September, marking the end of the summer holiday season, causing employers in the travel and lodging industry to reduce their overall staffing levels."
Not accurate
But Gary King, hospitality sector leader at the Recruitment and Employment Confederation, said Monster's findings did not accurately reflect the market.
"July and August were unusually busy this year, and although the market continued to rise in September, it did slow down slightly," he said. "But it is still buoyant, and there certainly hasn't been a drop in vacancies. Monster is one of many online recruitment sites, and its Employment Index does not seem to be a true reflection of the market."
This was echoed by Michael Carter, people services partner at consultancy KPMG, who pointed to a report from business researchers NTC Economics which suggested the market continued to grow in September, albeit at a slower rate.
"Although the increase in both permanent and temporary placements was at its lowest for five months, September's figures show continued robust demand for staff," he said.